Sector
Retailers Embracing Mobile Check-Out
Will retail sales clerks be roving the aisles this holiday season, ready to ring up your purchase with an iPad? Don’t count on it, but a new study suggests retailers are interested in the Apple tablet’s potential as a handheld register.
“Retailers have longed for moderately priced handheld devices for their sales associates and store managers to enhance the consumer experience,” according to the report by research and consulting firm IHL Group working with RetailConnections, which operates retail industry events. With the debut of the $500 iPad and other devices, some retailers are looking to eliminate point-of-sale (POS) or checkout locations in stores altogether.
Staff at Apple’s own stores carry iPod touch devices outfitted with a hard plastic case for scanning barcodes and swiping credit cards. They also have a stylus attached for customers to sign for credit charges. In my experience, it definitely beats standing in a long line to check out, especially during the holidays.
Barnes & Noble, Victoria’s Secret and Urban Outfitters are among other companies that have moved to equip in-store salespeople with handheld devices for speeding up the check-out process. Nearly 20% of specialty retailers plan to replace traditional POS with mobile check-out in the next two years.
The study also found retailers are warming to adoption of the iPhone among managers. While only 19% of retailers today support executives’ use of the Apple device for work, that proportion is expected to triple to 60% in the next 12 months. Similarly, iPad adoption is forecast to jump from 5% to 47% in the next year.
A survey last month of 200 companies in the U.S. and the U.K. by Sanford C. Bernstein & Co. found that 74% allow workers to use devices other than BlackBerrys.
On the consumer side, IHL Group found both the iPhone and Android-based phones taking center stage in the smartphone world. More than 56% of smartphone users are seriously considering an iPhone and 44% an Android device for their next phone. By contrast, only 24% are seriously looking at getting a BlackBerry, and only 10% a Windows smartphone.
“The iPhone is quickly replacing the BlackBerry in the mindshare of consumers and the executive office for many retailers,” noted Greg Buzek, president of IHL.
Among mobile-commerce findings, the study said 35% of smartphone users have received or redeemed a coupon received via text message and 41% have checked competitive prices while in a retail store using Amazon, Red Laser, or another comparison shopping tool.
And more than half (54%) of retailers surveyed indicated they’ll be able to scan customer coupons directly at the point-of-sale from a user’s mobile phone screen. Toys “R” Us, for instance, announced today that its stores nationwide now have the ability to scan mobile coupons and e-gifts at check-out.
The IHL/RetailConnections findings were based on a survey of 570 consumers and 66 retailers.
by Mark Walsh, Tuesday, November 9, 2010, 3:15 PM
Mobile GPS Search Data Shows Users Look For Fast Food, Hotels, Coffee And Walmarts
TeleNav today released interesting usage data on which brands mobile users are searching for using the company’s many mobile GPS navigation applications.
Of its more than 17 million subscribers, TeleNav analyzed how frequently its users entered brand names as a keyword searches, and found that select brands in a variety of vertical industries are beating out the competition for their share of mobile, local searches. ”Our GPS navigation users are in their vehicles, actively looking for a specific service or business to drive to,” explained Ky Tang, director of marketing for TeleNav. ”Our analysis of the businesses our users are actively searching for helps brands understand the behavior and preferences of on-the-go consumers.”
For example, fast food is obviously searched for more than others, with the data showing six of the top ten most searched restaurants in the Nation being fast-food locations. McDonald’s tops the charts as the number one searched restaurant, with more than twice as many searches as second place Subway. Taco Bell, KFC and Burger King round out the top five, respectively. Hotels are another highly searched vertical, with Holiday Inn being the number one searched for hotel with nearly twice as many searches for its properties than second place Marriott. Hampton took third place, followed by Motel 6 and Hilton.
In terms of shopping, TeleNav analyzed data to determine which large retail stores consumers search for most while on the road. Interestingly, the results found that Walmart tops the list by far, with more than three times as many searches as second place Target. Even more surprising, Walmart also holds the distinction as being the top searched keyword overall among TeleNav users. Of course, this data was released to show the immense marketing potential TeleNav’s new mobile advertising platform can provide.
The company recently launched its navigation-based mobile-ad platform to enable businesses, such as restaurants, hotels and retail stores, to place a sponsored listing at the top of the search results located in its mobile navigation applications. When users click on the sponsored listing, the advertiser can provide additional information to the user such as a coupon or menu information. The user can then choose to call, map or receive turn-by-turn directions to drive to the business location, all of which are actions TeleNav measures and reports as metrics to advertisers.
“This usage analysis demonstrates the wealth of data and insights we have into what drivers are searching for when they’re on the road,” said Tang. “If a brand is not a top searched destination, they can use our ad platform to place their listing at the top of the search results list, giving them more visibility with our users. If the brand is already frequently searched by our users, our ad platform can be used to include deals or coupons within their listings, rewarding consumers for being loyal to their brand and helping to increase the number of users who choose to visit a location after conducting a search.”
Spanish Mobile Advertising Campaign For Audi Sees 50,000 Impressions In A Matter Of Days
A recent mobile advertising campaign for Audi’s new A1 model in Spain achieved impressive results in a matter of days using a rich media video ad unit recently introduced by TAPTAP Networks and GoldSpot Media — two leading mobile video solution providers in Spain.
The new format used in the Audi campaign is the result of a recent collaboration between the aforementioned companies, including interstitial video and video banners ads. At the heart of the solution is a way to re-purpose TV commercials into mobile video campaigns for mobile apps and the mobile Web. Both video solutions allow users to watch a commercial on their mobile device while loading at app startup or while navigating through apps.
The campaign in question was ran in Spain’s leading iPhone sports application AS.com, and engaged users with a full-screen video interstitial upon starting the app. The campaign quickly saw huge success, garnering more than 50,000 impressions in just a few days and achieving more than eight seconds of average viewing time per user.
“We’re extremely happy with the initial campaign results. Many more top tier brands are interested in trying these new video formats in the short term,” said Alvaro del Castillo, CEO of TAPTAP Networks. “Advertisers are looking for new ways to stand out in a fragmented media landscape and we’ve found that mobile video provides the best opportunity to generate great awareness and strong brand recognition with the mobile audience.”
Text Coupons Most Popular Retail-related Consumer Mobile Activity
Eight in 10 US mobile phone users currently uses or will use mobile text coupons within 24 months, according to [pdf] a new study from IHL Group and RetailConnections. Looking at a variety of retail-related consumer mobile activities, text coupons lead both in terms of current engagement (25%) and planned engagement in the next 12 months (47%). Probably due to the high percentage of consumers who will already be using mobile text coupons within 12 months, planned engagement within 12 to 24 months is only 9%, tied for second-lowest with consumer self-checkout.
The other two retail-related consumer mobile activities currently used by more than 20% of mobile phone subscribers are regular barcode (22%) and 2D barcode (21%). Coupons on mobile screen only have 16% current engagement, but 38% planned engagement within the next 12 months, second only to text coupons in this category.
iPhone/iPod Most Supported Consumer Mobile Platform by Wide Margin
Study data indicates 85% of US retailers support consumer use of the iPhone/iPod platform, and 88% plan to do so in the future. This current support rate dwarfs the 55% support of the next-most-popular consumer mobile platform among retailers, the iPad platform. However, 72% of retailers plan to support consumer iPad use in the future.
While only 50% of retailers currently support consumer use of the Android platform, 79% plan to support it in the future. Windows Mobile has 43% current support and 53% planned support, while Blackberry has slightly lower current support (40%) but slightly higher future support (58%).
4 in 10 Retailers Support Store Associate Blackberry Platform
Retailers display different preferences for supporting mobile platform use by their employees, and at much lower percentages. Part of the reason for this lower level of support may be the higher cost involved in supplying store associates with mobile devices, as opposed to letting consumers use their own devices in the store.
The iPhone/iPod and Windows Mobile platforms are tied for second place with 42% current support. However, 67% of retailers plan future iPhone/iPod support, while only 41% plan future Windows Mobile support, implying a small number of retailers currently supporting employee use of Windows Mobile devices plan to end it.
Android only has 26% current support, but comparatively high 41% planned future support. Windows CE/7 also has 26% current support, but similar to Windows Mobile planned future support for this platform dips to 22%.
Texting Most Popular Mobile Plan Feature
Perhaps explaining the popularity of text coupons, more than nine in 10 mobile phone owners (94%) have text included in their phone plan, according to other study results. This makes texting by far the most popular feature of US consumer mobile phone plans. Other popular features include email (80%) and mobile web (78%).
About the Data: The data for this study were obtained by performing a web-based survey during the August-September 2010 timeframe. A total of 570 responses were used, of which 66 were retailers.
Tag-Along Marketing
As of August, only 4 percent of American adults who used the Internet also used location-based services, which allow people to “check in” to physical locations via their cellphones to earn coupons or keep up with friends, the Pew Research Center’s Internet and American Life Project reported last week. And only 1 percent of Internet users are on such services on any given day, an indication that those who do use the services still have not integrated them into their daily lives.
On any given day, 1 percent of adult Americans use a service that allows them to share their location, according to the report. Four percent of adult Internet users use location-based services at all, down from 5 percent of Internet users who said they used such services in May. Only 6 percent of people who use social networking sites also used location-based services.
People using location-based services fit the profile of any early adopter of new technologies, said Kathryn Zickuhr, the author of the report.
Men were twice as likely as women to use location-based services, and people between 18 and 29 years old were more than twice as likely to use them as any other adult age group. The Pew report did not include data on teenagers.
Ten percent of Hispanics reported using location-based services, compared with 5 percent of blacks and 3 percent of whites.
Ms. Zickuhr said she was surprised at how companies building location into their business plans seemed to be far ahead of people using such services in their day-to-day lives.
Still, companies like Foursquare and Gowalla, two of the leaders in the location-based services market, have had no trouble raising money from investors. Advertisers are on track to spend $1.8 billion on location-based marketing in 2015, according to ABI Research, a technology market research firm.
And last week, Facebook announced that it would allow retailers to offer coupons and special deals through its own location-based service, Places, which it introduced in August.
How did businesses get so far ahead of consumers on this idea? And will consumers ever catch up?
In order to answer this question, it helps to understand how technology companies make money by providing free services. When a customer buys a toothbrush from a drugstore, she pays with cash; when the same customer creates a social-networking profile on Facebook, the currency she uses is her personal data.
Specific user data is valuable to advertisers because it allows them to target their marketing efforts more effectively. With social networking, hundreds of millions of people are willing to provide access to that data in exchange for a service they find useful, even while many express concerns about their privacy.
“Many people are in a more ‘transactional’ frame of mind” when it comes to their personal information, said Lee Rainie, the director of the Internet and American Life Project. “They will share information if they think they can get something of value for it.”
Data about a person’s physical location would be immensely valuable to marketers and retailers, say analysts. But sharing information about where you are can seem creepy or, worse, dangerous, as the Web site Please Rob Me showed earlier this year when it demonstrated how easy it would be for potential thieves to use social networks to find homes whose occupants were away.
Meanwhile, the upside of the transaction is unclear to many people, said Melissa Parrish, an analyst at Forrester Research. None of the efforts so far have reached the “sweet spot of coolness and utility” that will get people to share their data, she said.
Josh Williams, a founder of Gowalla, agreed, describing the way that location-based services are pitched as “nerdy and often off-putting.”
Mr. Williams said Facebook’s efforts would show people an upside to location via special offers on shopping through its Deals program. His company and others are working on less tangible benefits, like providing an opportunity to connect with friends in the physical world. He acknowledged that the companies still had to show people the point of all this.
“As an industry, it behooves ourselves to look for more human ways to explain what we’re doing,” he said.
Millennial Media: 82M Users On The Mobile Web, Finance Vertical Grows 800%
Millennial Media has published its S.M.A.R.T report for the month of September, detailing stats from Q3 as seen from its unique audience reach of 73.5M users — or roughly 8 out of 10 mobile Web users.
Starting with general stats, Millennial reports the US mobile Web increased by approximately 3% since its last report, growing from 80M in August to over 82M in September. Other quick stats include 12% of advertisers on Millennial’s network used rich media elements in their campaigns during Q3 — up significantly from the start of the year — showing advertisers are broadening their strategy as smartphones and more capable devices continue to proliferate.
With October being Breast Cancer Awareness month, advertisers are focusing on how to reach women. As such, this month’s report details findings from InsightExpress’ Q2 2010 Digital Consumer Portrait, which focused on moms and how they engage with mobile. The findings show 32% of moms own a smartphone in 2010, a surprisingly high number if you ask me, which is up significantly from the 20% reported in 2009 — a 60% increase year-over-year. Thirty-two percent of moms also said they use the mobile Web at least once per week in 2010, compared to just 20% in 2009 — again, a 60% increase.
In terms of the verticals represented on Millennial’s network, several continue to see substantial increases. Six advertising verticals saw triple-digit year-over-year growth, and surprisingly, the verticals that have experienced this tremendous growth were all in the Top 10 AdvertisingVertical Ranking in Q3 2009 as well. For example, entertainment claimed the number one spot in Q3, showing growth of 315% year-over-year. The finance vertical has seen explosive growth as well, posting a whopping 800% growth year-over-year, while retail and restaurants showed an impressive growth rate of 745% as well. In all, nearly all verticals being represented via mobile advertising have grown significantly, with no signs of slowing down any time soon.
As usual, much more information, data points and visual representations are available in the actual report, which can be downloaded here.
Mobile Users Prefer Mobile Web not Apps
Even though mobile apps seem to get all the attention these days, consumer sentiment towards the debate between apps vs. the mobile Web show preference for the latter, in a big way.
eMarketer came out with data yesterday detailing a poll by Keynote Systems for Adobe that shows overwhelming consumer preference for mobile browsers to access virtually all mobile content. Games, music and social media were the only categories in which users would rather use a downloaded app than browse the mobile Web.
The retail category in particular shows an overwhelming preference for mobile Web access across nearly all mobile shopping tasks mentioned. Whether it was researching product and price info or sharing that information socially, mobile users would rather fire up a browser than a dedicated app. Interestingly, When the Adobe survey asked about a preference for using regular or mobile-optimized websites on their mobile device, they preferred regular sites in both the consumer products-shopping and media-entertainment categories.
According to the report, this preference suggests “a low awareness of optimized experiences for the mobile web,” but users could also be frustrated with the limited functionality many mobile-optimized sites provide. These results fall in line with most marketers in the retail space who say mobile apps don’t make sense for brand retailers. For example, during his keynote at the Mobile Shopping Summit in New York recently, a Kenneth Cole executive said that — especially with the rise of HTML5 — his company’s focus is on the mobile Web going forward.
“Looking at the mobile sites of mass merchants, look-up sites and brand retailers, they are all using different design templates and tactics to get their message across,” said Tom Davis, vice president of ecommerce at Kenneth Cole Productions. “This year we put our toe in the water, but we expect sales driven by mobile devices to be bigger than some of our bricks-and-mortar stores.
New Data on Mobile Marketing Alerts
Today Placecast announced the release of their second wave of research conducted by Harris Interactive that dives deeper into consumer receptivity to opt-in mobile marketing and the potential impact for retailers. Overall, consumer receptivity to opt-in mobile marketing is growing, as is its ability to increase intent to visit stores. One-third of Americans who currently have signed up for mobile marketing alerts indicate that such services impact their decision to go into stores and 27% report that mobile programs have impacted their decision to buy products in physical retail locations. (Please click here to request more information covered in this study).
During the summer of 2009, we conducted the first survey on location-based mobile marketing and advertising, which forms the baseline for this research. Since that first survey, we have seen that overall consumer interest in such programs increased with ‘somewhat interested’ consumers growing by 2 percent to 28% of all cell phone owners. As in the first survey, interest is most pronounced among the youngest cell phone owners: 42% of those ages 18–34 are at least somewhat interested. Interest grew 6 points to 40% among women ages 18–34 from the survey conducted in 2009. Interest levels between men and women are now about equal overall.
Consumers vote with their stomachs Groceries (68%), national restaurant chains (64%), and fast-food items (50%) took three of the top four most popular segments for those who are at least somewhat receptive to overall opt-in mobile marketing, with a host of other categories also seeing strong interest.
Women skewed higher than men when it came to interest in offers/promotions for groceries and apparel, while men skewed higher in interest for electronics and sporting goods products:
Texting significantly more valued than app-based services One of the most interesting data points in this study across all cell phone owners is the importance of texting: it is still an overwhelmingly popular activity on mobile vs. other activities. An average of 40% of all cell phone owners say that texting is “extremely” or “very important” to them. Even with the buzz of services like Foursquare and Gowalla, only 7% of men and 3% of women showed the same level of interest in these types of social networks
With check-in services only available on smart phones (which comprise roughly 21% of all mobile phones in the U.S.), reach for marketers through these platforms is still a question. Furthermore, both consumers and marketers see texting as similar mechanisms to email, which has made a substantial impact on purchase behavior— both online and in brick-and-mortar stores.
Incorporating location—the ability to make messages even more relevant based on where users are and when they are there—is consistently seen as a valuable service by consumers and is easy for marketers to execute at scale.
Methodology This survey was conducted online within the United States by Harris Interactive on behalf of Placecast from May 17–19, 2010 among 2,046 U.S. adults ages 18+, of whom 1,710 own a cell phone and/or a smartphone. For complete survey methodology, including weighting variables, please contact us here.
